This is a curated editorial account maintained by Quiet Banger. All ratings are sourced from the publication's publicly available reviews.
Taste
Islands

A Sleep & A Forgetting
Islands

Ski Mask
Islands

Smiley Smile
The Beach Boys

Should I Remain Here At Sea?
Islands

Tall Tall Shadow
Basia Bulat

Woman King
Iron & Wine

Oh, My Darling
Basia Bulat
Weed Garden
Iron & Wine

Heart of My Own
Basia Bulat

Sing Into My Mouth
Iron and Wine & Ben Bridwell

The Sea & the Rhythm
Iron & Wine

Our Endless Numbered Days
Iron & Wine
Love Letter for Fire
Sam Beam & Jesca Hoop
Kiss Each Other Clean
Iron & Wine

In the Reins
Calexico | Iron & Wine

Ghost on Ghost
Iron & Wine

Sad Hunk
Bahamas

Beast Epic
Iron & Wine
Archive Series Volume No. 5: Tallahassee Recordings
Iron and Wine

Pink Strat
Bahamas

Archive Series, Volume No. 1
Iron and Wine

Quality Control
Jurassic 5

Trying Times
James Blake

Love
The Juliana Theory

The Speed of Things
Dale Earnhardt Jr. Jr.

JR JR
JR JR

It's a Corporate World
Dale Earnhardt Jr. Jr.
Invocations / Conversations
JR JR

The Well-Tempered Clavier I
Johann Sebastian Bach; Maurizio Pollini
Sermon on the Rocks
Josh Ritter

Barchords
Bahamas
The Historical Conquests of Josh Ritter
Josh Ritter

Bahamas is Afie
Bahamas
Hello Starling
Josh Ritter

Vestiges & Claws
José González

One Plus One Is One
Badly Drawn Boy

Veneer
José González
Local Valley
José González

In Our Nature
José González
Have You Fed the Fish?
Badly Drawn Boy

About a Boy
Badly Drawn Boy

White Wilderness
John Vanderslice

True Sadness
The Avett Brothers

Romanian Names
John Vanderslice

Pixel Revolt
John Vanderslice

Magpie and the Dandelion
The Avett Brothers

Dagger Beach
John Vanderslice
Cellar Door
John Vanderslice

In Spite of Ourselves
John Prine

From the Ground Up
John Fullbright

Order of Romance
Jesca Hoop

Cover The Mirrors
Ben Kweller

Memories Are Now
Jesca Hoop

When I Said I Wanted to Be Your Dog
Jens Lekman
The Beethoven Journey: Piano Concerto no. 5 / Choral Fantasy
Beethoven; Mahler Chamber Orchestra, Leif Ove Andsnes

The Linden Trees Are Still in Blossom
Jens Lekman
The Carpenter
The Avett Brothers
Life Will See You Now
Jens Lekman

I Know What Love Isn’t
Jens Lekman

Correspondence
Jens Lekman & Annika Norlin

The Cherry Trees Are Still in Blossom
Jens Lekman

Reflektor
Arcade Fire

Vol. 3… Life and Times of S. Carter
JAY‐Z

The Blueprint²: The Gift & The Curse
Jay‐Z

Yours Truly, the Commuter
Jason Lytle

Dept. of Disappearance
Jason Lytle

Everything Now
Arcade Fire

Mud Slide Slim and the Blue Horizon
James Taylor
Gorilla
James Taylor
Green to Gold
The Antlers

Sweet Baby James
James Taylor
Assume Form
James Blake

Sing-A-Longs and Lullabies for the Film Curious George
Jack Johnson

On and On
Jack Johnson
In Between Dreams
Jack Johnson

Your Majesty
The Anniversary

Brushfire Fairytales
Jack Johnson

Greatest Hits
Sublime

Pig Lib
Stephen Malkmus and the Jicks

Absolutes
Stavesacre

Friction
Stavesacre

Good Woman
The Staves

Built on Squares
Starlight Mints
The Dream That Stuff Was Made Of
Starlight Mints

MASSEDUCTION
St. Vincent
They Want My Soul
Spoon

I Am Sam: Music From and Inspired by the Motion Picture
Various Artists

Didn’t It Rain
Songs: Ohia

Axxess & Ace
Songs: Ohia

Much Against Everyone’s Advice
Soulwax

Irresistible Bliss
Soul Coughing

Ruby Vroom
Soul Coughing

Tramp
Sharon Van Etten

Calenture
The Triffids

Foo Fighters
Foo Fighters
MY WOMAN
Angel Olsen
Burn Your Fire for No Witness
Angel Olsen

The Execution of All Things
Rilo Kiley

so sad so sexy
Lykke Li

Writer’s Block
Peter Bjorn and John
I Never Learn
Lykke Li

The Party
Andy Shauf

Food & Liquor II: The Great American Rap Album, Pt. 1
Lupe Fiasco

The Lumineers
The Lumineers

Cleopatra
The Lumineers

Snowbeast
Luke Temple

The Neon Skyline
Andy Shauf

Don't Act Like You Don't Care
Luke Temple

In a Time Lapse
Ludovico Einaudi

The Bearer of Bad News
Andy Shauf

What's on My Mind?
The Dayton Family
Weather Systems
Andrew Bird

Lost on You
LP
The Great Destroyer
Low
Drums and Guns
Low

Things Are Really Great Here, Sort of…
Andrew Bird

Sing Along With Acid House Kings
Acid House Kings

Ones and Sixes
Low
Libraries
The Love Language

Music Sounds Better With You
Acid House Kings

The Love Language
The Love Language
All Alone in an Empty House
Lost in the Trees

No Blues
Los Campesinos!

Strange Trails
Lord Huron

Lonesome Dreams
Lord Huron
Violet Street
Local Natives

Sunlit Youth
Local Natives

These 13
Jimbo Mathus & Andrew Bird

Hummingbird
Local Natives
Lo Tom
Lo Tom
Light Green Leaves
Little Wings

American Dream
LCD Soundsystem

Mr. M
Lambchop

All Mirrors
Angel Olsen
I Want the Door to Open
Lala Lala
No P. or D.
Ms. John Soda
We Shall All Be Healed
The Mountain Goats
My Finest Work Yet
Andrew Bird

Transcendental Youth
The Mountain Goats

Songs for Pierre Chuvin
The Mountain Goats

Seven Swans
Sufjan Stevens

How It Feels to Be Something On
Sunny Day Real Estate

LP2
Sunny Day Real Estate

Cunningham Bird
Andrew Bird & Madison Cunningham

No Rules Sandy
Sylvan Esso
There’s No Leaving Now
The Tallest Man on Earth

Shake the Sheets
Ted Leo + Pharmacists
Thao & Mirah
Thao & Mirah

The Spine
They Might Be Giants

Mink Car
They Might Be Giants

Lincoln
They Might Be Giants

Flood
They Might Be Giants

So Much for the City
The Thrills

Lovage
Timber Timbre

Creep On Creepin’ On
Timber Timbre

Sprinter
TORRES

10 Songs
Travis

12 Memories
Travis

Summerteeth
Wilco

A Ghost Is Born
Wilco

See Mystery Lights
YACHT

The Mistress
Yellow Ostrich